It started as a chatbot. Now it’s making business decisions.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Remember when AI was just the office toy?

Someone would feed it a prompt during lunch, you’d laugh at the weird output, screenshot it for Slack, and go back to work. That was January.

By March, it was approving purchase orders.

AI used to be a fun experiment, write a prompt, get a paragraph, laugh at the weird parts. Now it’s routing invoices, flagging fraud, approving access, and writing donor emails. In short: it grew up faster than the people managing it.

The shift happened quietly. One day you’re experimenting with automated responses. The next, you’re explaining to finance why the system flagged every invoice from your biggest vendor. No warning. No training. Just sudden responsibility for something you never explicitly agreed to own.

The problem? Most organizations still treat AI like a gadget, not a system. They celebrate results but skip the part where someone takes responsibility.

The AI Accountability Checklist

If your team can’t answer these five questions, your AI is still in its toddler phase:

1. Who owns this AI?

Every automation needs a name beside it, not a committee, a person. When something breaks at 3 AM, you need to know who gets the call. When a decision needs explaining to the board, you need to know whose credibility is on the line.

Ownership isn’t punishment, it’s clarity.

2. What data feeds it?

If the source is unclear, the risk is already real. AI is only as good as what you feed it. If you can’t trace the data pipeline from source to output, you can’t debug the system when it makes a bad call.

And it will make a bad call.

3. How often is it reviewed?

Governance without a schedule is just faith. “We’ll check it when something goes wrong” isn’t a review cycle it’s a disaster plan.

Monthly? Quarterly? After every major data refresh? Pick a cadence and stick to it.

4. Who can pause it?

Someone must hold the red button and know when to press it. The fastest way to lose trust isn’t having a problem. It’s letting that problem run unchecked because no one had permission to stop it.

5. What’s the audit trail?

Logs are memory. Memory prevents lawsuits. When someone asks “why did the system do that?” six months from now, you need receipts. Not guesses. Not “I think it was configured to…” Actual documentation.

What This Actually Looks Like

A client once bragged about an “autonomous” case-resolution bot that saved 300 hours a month.

It also deleted 12 open cases with incomplete data.

Turns out “autonomy” meant “no one was watching.” The bot had a rule: cases flagged as “pending information” for more than 30 days get auto-closed. Made sense on paper. In practice, it closed legitimate cases where clients were in the middle of gathering documents.

No one caught it because no one was checking. The first hint of a problem came when an angry client called asking why their case vanished mid-process.

After introducing the Accountability Checklist, they built a rotation for manual spot-checks every Tuesday, someone reviews a random sample of 20 automated decisions.

Productivity dipped 3 percent. Accuracy rose 17 percent.

Worth it? Completely.

The cost of review is predictable. The cost of mistakes is not.

The Question That Matters

AI maturity isn’t about the model’s intelligence it’s about your organization’s willingness to admit when it’s wrong.

Before the next automation rolls out, ask one question:

Would I still trust this system if my name were on every single output?

If the answer makes you uncomfortable, congratulations you’ve found your next governance task.

Jeremy’s Tip: If no one owns the output, everyone will own the fallout.

Jeremy Carmona is a journalist turned Salesforce architect who believes technology should make people’s work simpler, not harder. He founded Clear Concise Consulting to help professionals and nonprofits make sense of Salesforce without jargon or chaos. He’s known for teaching with humor, cutting through hype, and building frameworks that turn “What does this even mean?” into “Got it.”